"Taste The Difference"


Timothy's Pizzeria has been delivering excellent quality pizza and Italian specialties to the Centerport community for over 30 years. We pride ourselves on consistently delivering this quality.

We have been family owned and operated since 1988 and have continuously delivered across a generation. Mike Giuliani, owner and pizza chef, started in the pizzeria business when he was a teenager, honing his skills over the decades to perfect the best possible pizza pie.

Whether you want a traditional neopolitan pie (our specialty), a Chicago Deep-Dish pie, a Sicilian pie, a Gluten Free* pie, or wish to try our specialty slices like buffalo chicken, tomato and spinach, cauliflower, or even antipasto, we will not disappoint. And, if you want something other than pizza, our menu has many other delicious options. Pick from a selection of hot or cold heroes, salad, wings, appetizers, sausage rolls, calzones or other options. We are constantly cooking new options to keep our menu varied and to meet the changing tastes of our customers.

If you have a larger event planned, don’t forget about our catering options. We offer a wide selection of trays and salads to make your next party a culinary success.

We take pride in both our employees and our ingredients. All of our ingredients and food are prepared in small batches daily to ensure freshness and quality. We feel that our strict adherance to quality has been why we have been recognized by Newsday as one of the top pizzerias in Western Suffolk and have been said to have the best garlic knots on the Island. This is what our loyal customers expect of us and what we deliver.

We welcome new customers and look to make them customers for life. If you haven't tried our pizza yet please consider coming down or giving us a call. We are located at 10B Little Neck Road, Centerport or call in a pick-up or delivery order on the phone at (631)-261-4020. You'll find our staff friendly and helpful. Delivery service is free on any order $12 or more. Also feel free to try our curbside pickup. Thank you!

About Michael:

As a lifelong resident and community member of Huntington, he is a proud contributor to the local community. He works with many nearby groups like the Centerport Fire Department, the many nearby churches, schools, the Boy Scouts, Girl Scouts and most recently Huntington Hospital.

Consistency is something Mike holds close in his values among the pizzeria. He's honored to continue the tradition that his family began over thirty years ago before Mike took over. The generations of customers that grew up on Timothy's cuisine come back many years later only to say that it tastes the same... Delicious!

---- Store Hours ----

Sun - Thurs                                    11 AM - 9:30 PM
Fri - Sat                                             11 AM - 10 PM
* Closing hours may vary                               

Family Owned and Operated for Over 30 Years!

Owner: Mike Giuliani